Your cart is currently empty.
Enable cookies to use the shopping cart
Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout
Halloween and Thanksgiving preorders available
creamy cinnamon pudding folded into chunks of cinnamon roll
layers of vanilla wafers, fresh bananas and creamy vanilla pudding
our creamy vanilla pudding folded into chunks of chcolate chip banana mandel bread made exclusively by Michael’s Mand...
delicious vanilla pudding folded with vanilla wafers, fresh bananas and Nutella
creamy guayaba and cream cheese pudding layered with María cookies
boozy puddings are spiked with rum
creamy chocolate pudding folded with Nutella and Oreo cookies
Tipsies are spiked with chocolate liqueur
Showing 6 of 15 products on Our Menu collection
creamy pumpkin pudding folded with gingersnap cookies
pick your favorite Halloween bowl or jar and add a note at checkout with your flavor selection(s)
each bowl serves a...
layers of salted caramel cookies and fresh bananas between creamy vanilla pudding covered with salted caramel sauce
traditional Coquito with a homemade pumpkin twist
holiday gift box with 5 half pints of assorted flavors… drop us a note with your 5 flavor picks!
Want us to a include a note card with your Pudding Parlor gift? No problem! We will personalize the card for you!
We all have a side hustle... what’s yours? You can now have our very own and exclusive pink and apron designed in go...
Receive a free pudding cup today through Saturday with the purchase of any gift card!
Need to keep your order cool? We can package it for you in this biodegradable cooler with dry ice.